Skip to content
Ethics & Governance

Hallucinated Citations Keep Landing Lawyers in Trouble, and the Penalties Are Rising

Masters Media

Six-figure fines, an indefinite suspension and a BigLaw admission show courts have moved past warnings.

Masters AI 1 min read

More than three years after Mata v. Avianca, AI-fabricated citations are still turning up in court filings, and the consequences are getting steeper. Two Oregon attorneys were hit with about $110,000 in fines and fees over federal filings full of hallucinated cites. The Nebraska Supreme Court indefinitely suspended a lawyer whose brief contained 57 faulty or nonexistent citations out of 63. Even Sullivan & Cromwell acknowledged that a filing in a major Manhattan bankruptcy case cited cases that don’t exist.

Damien Charlotin’s tracker counted 2,184 AI-hallucination court cases worldwide as of Oct 10, 2026, 1,492 of them in the US.

Why it matters: Courts are moving from warnings to real financial and licensing penalties, and no firm is too big to be caught. Every lawyer using AI needs a verification step for every citation. Firms should treat cite-checking as a matter of written policy, not individual habit.

Read more: It’s no hallucination: AI-generated errors persist in court filings (Virginia Lawyers Weekly)